

We burn resources faster when we centralize, in most cases, where applicable.
Centralisation is generally more efficient due to various economies of scale such as fixed capital costs, greater division of labour and larger R&D budgets. Since centralised facilities are more efficient, they will gradually outcompete and buy out / drive out smaller competitors. There are two ways to deal with the negative consequences of this tendency - (1) give smaller competitors an advantage by breaking up / penalising the largest ones, or (2) bringing the largest competitors under public control through nationalisation. But the centralising tendency itself is a sort of natural economic law that applies under most conditions.
The point of centralization is always about control.
This is a consequence, not a cause.


I think this is one of the few cases where the CEO’s position does matter. There has been a schism within the US govt and tech sector over whether or not to sell AI chips to China. Jensen Huang was the unofficial leader of the ‘yes’ faction, arguing that it would cut Huawei’s marketshare (and therefore R&D budget). Of course, Nvidia being allowed to sell chips to more customers is in his interest, so he isn’t entirely neutral here. Now the US govt and US customers of Nvidia’s chips will demand further restrictions on chip sales to China. In the short term, their sales will fall slightly. In the long-term, Huawei will overtake them.