The domain https://fediverse.observer/ redirects to sedo now.
On October 11th these two commits where made to the repo:
this will be my final release, glad to have contributed since 2011 to some fediverse stats, https://fedidb.com/ is a great resource with more interest
this software is no longer developed
Sad to have lost such a great resource.


A lot of the problems with Lemmy boil down ultimately to overall lack of moderation. Many people were banned from Reddit for many reasons, among them including an extreme level of toxicity, so the need for such is dire - that is, assuming that our goal is not to provide a safe space for everyone to vent their feelings, and instead to offer a space welcoming to newcomers. The recent thread in the Fediverse community praising the devs of many Fediverse platforms is a great example: it became highly toxic, ultimately being locked.
So (1) we need to identify what we are. Some places, like dbzero and anarchist nexus will choose to become more like 4chan, with the admins themselves literally flinging actual death threats against admins of other instances. Others, like PieFed.Social, will become more actively hostile against such trolling and tankie (and tankie-supporting) behaviors. So there will never be a solution to this step that involves all of us getting onto the same page.
The problem here comes from lack of transparency. Hexbear’s Chapotraphouse is fairly open about what it is… though many 3rd-party apps bury the sidebar quote deep into their menus, especially if you encounter a post on All and so you will basically never see it. I do decry the right of places such as Chapotraphouse to exist, but I do think that they need to be labeled properly, with a warning label, so that non-extremist mainstream normal folks do not encounter them unawares, and by virtue of their inclusion and lack of distinction from any other content here, think that the entire Threadiverse is a tankie haven, full of extremists who support genocide and the violent, bloody overthrow of the entire Western civilization.
PieFed made huge strides towards this regard. Most 3rd-party apps barely support any PieFed features that differ from base Lemmy, but at least the browser UX is somewhat better, in some ways.
However, PieFed advancement in this regard seems to have ground to a halt before picking up speed in the opposite direction. But to focus on the former for a moment, e.g. the instance picker (the last time I checked) was very confusing and came nowhere close to explaining what individual users could expect when signing up to an instance. Fortunately PyLova has picked up the slack here and advanced that cause significantly forward. Unfortunately, PieFed seems to be continually actively working against this goal now, making the options more opaque rather than transparent - e.g. any PieFed community on an instance that does not explicitly disable the downvote feature (and which ones have done that? how is anyone supposed to know!?) is shadow-censoring contributions offered from many different software platforms (Lemmy, Mbin, nodeBB, Friendica, Mastodon, etc.), without disclosure of that fact. However, I see no acknowledgement of that fact at e.g. https://feddit.online/auth/instance_chooser, where for PieFed.Social the closest item of explanation offered seems to be “Newbie friendly: yes”.
Only after someone has been guided into picking an instance does the futher steps matter, like (2) picking a 3rd-party app (sigh… I guess to most Redditors, this is mandatory?), and (3) helping them sign up to discover new content (this PieFed excels at, at least at the software level even though many instances like PieFed.World do not take full advantage by fleshing out the Topic Areas). Though then comes (4) retaining people, which is where most of our exceedingly poor reputation seems to stem from, as people who jumped through all of the prior hurdles flee this toxic shithole, which simultaneously barely has any content and yet what content it does offer to people unfortunately turns people away due to how toxic it all is. I do think that Rimu had the right idea behind a lot of his social credit features - e.g. if someone is extremely often downvoted, by let’s say “like-minded” instances (however that might be defined - e.g. it could be anti-genocide, or it could even be the opposite of pro-genocide, or neutral, or whatever), then their account name begins to come with a warning ⚠️ label, so that people do not stumble into a conversation completely unawares. Not everyone wants this space to be even more like 4chan than it already is - some do, but mainstream normal folks have spoken, and they refuse to come here because it is already too much like it for their tastes.
People demand freedom. Which ultimately means some restrictions must be placed, so as to protect others, e.g. people must not be free to say whatever they want, even against the wishes of the recipients, or else we have no freedom here at all. Voat & nostr already proved that: even the spaces that reputedly values “free speech” the most ended up as wastelands where nobody wanted to venture into, due to having no freedom to not listen to such vitriol literally 100% of the time (without any recourse to block it even for a moment, except to flee entirely).
So now it’s a cache-22 where we won’t get more content without more people, who refuse to come here. And also they demand 3rd-party apps, whose devs look to me to be tired on working to support new features, especially for PieFed. PyLova might be the single best hope the entire Threadiverse has to grow. We’ll see what happens!
Yeah, I would say we are definitely at a “work-in-progress” level, with a ways to go.
I saw the post originally. Going back it looks like FiniteBanjo went to pick a fight. I’m not trying make any judgement on their comments, just that they appear, to me, to wanted to start an argument (“Well, not all of them. Some of them are a stain on this earth.”). Not surprised it was locked at that point.
My recollection and understanding of that situation was that it was an inferred threat, that, when confronted, was immediately rescinded and that admin stepped down due to their actions. So, I think, it’s a bit disingenuous to use that as a negative against them. To me, they responded appropriately when confronted with how their message was taken (clarification that’s not how it was intended and then stepping down from their position of authority).
I believe soon after the .world admins faked “evidence” that the anarchist admins were really fascists trying to sow discord or something (I don’t recall the exact allegation, but I remember the evidence being shown and confirmed to be fake). My recollection is Rimu backed the .world admins even after their evidence had been shown to be faked. I want to say that is when Rimu introduced the instance “silencing” feature, to reduce anarchist influence after his and the .world admins’ attempts to expel the anarchists with the faked evidence failed.
Decentralization. There doesn’t need to be, in my eyes.
On-boarding is a huge gap in my mind. From my view, we basically throw everyone in the deep-end and hope they learn to swim and aren’t too concerned with fixing the issue, because we all learned to swim, so why can’t they.
I could see an on-boarding that quickly explains the structure (like 2 sentences about decentralization/email-analogy and identifying a users name and instance. Then go into a quick questionnaire (for determining best host instance for them) about what kind of posts they want to see (one of those could be a quoted .ml account, to see if the new user wants to see “triad” content). From there some, basic filtering/block list yes/nos (block-list for spam accounts: yes/no, agentic accounts: yes/no, bot accounts: yes/no, etc.) and interested topics (software, cats, art, etc.). I think that would go a long way in helping get an easier and more welcoming environment (may only be fully possible via Pylova features at the moment (block-lists)).
That’s a good point I hadn’t thought of before. I’m not sure how an instance could keep a user informed without keeping a larger database of community and instance settings. Alternatively, sending that info for each load or interaction the user makes. The larger database sounds much more reasonable, but still daunting and not easily implemented and probably with a significant compute cost.
This isn’t surprising to me. Piefed has 20% of the users Lemmy has (and that increase to 20% is relatively recent) and developer generally want to get paid for their work (especially if they don’t have a main corporate job).
Yeah, definitely looks to be the brightest hope we have right now. Hopefully, they can keep up a sustainable pace and don’t burn out.
Agreed about FiniteBanjo but iirc that definitely was not the only one - and it makes sense that a mod would rather ban some singular individual (especially if only for a day or two) rather than lock an entire post over such. Reddit offers the ability to lock a particular thread within a post (including I believe replies underneath it?), but I forget if that is possible in Lemmy or not. The tools tend to be significantly more primitive here, even if not enshittified for reasons of profit, just shit instead for reasons of not enough effort put in as compared to a multi-million dollar corporation hiring full teams of dedicated programmers. And then add the constraints of requiring working within the ActivityPub Protocol to enact federation and it becomes clear how much more difficult this task is to not merely replace Reddit but expand beyond it.
Though the end users rarely seem to care about such things and instead simply want everything handed to them for free. That is what they were trained into becoming by an advertising driven model of the internet, and they see no reason to be anything else.
About the death threats; I never said that the threat was personal and direct. And actually I had forgotten about whatever accusations were faked or whatever, though that’s besides the point for my own topic here. Vague and unspecified death threats are still calls for literal violence and portrayals of a lawless mindset that encourages such. Which some of us here on the Threadiverse very much like, while others of us here are the opposite and merely tolerate it, but your average Redditor trends more towards having been groomed to enjoy the walled garden effect, or else has already been here. In any case I was pointing towards the death threats as evidence of disorder and fighting that leads away from stability, which in turn increases greatly the complexity of the Threadiverse that is mandatory to be understood prior to joining us here.
e.g. when/if the Flotilla defederates from Lemmy.world, that will impact a great many people. LW has >90% of the most active communities, and of the rest many have ended up via various migration effects on an instance that is a member of the Flotilla. New members will in virtually no way be guided into understanding any of this, leading to such posts as e.g. the recent one in Fediverse expressing absolute shock at having been banned from Lemmy.ml - as if that wasn’t a practically daily event here (or at least definitely would be if we had a sufficient populace to keep up that rate). We are fast falling into fragmentation, since we cannot maintain mutual respect. And especially if evidence really was being outright faked (I have no idea?), then all the more so.
I am not trying to suggest that such an action would signal the death knell for Lemmy, but the fact that it seemed imminent at one point and in fact is still high likely does not exactly signal health either, particularly in terms of a mindset of growth as opposed to mere existence.
I also am not opposed to decentralization, particularly since that’s already what we have now, but we should somewhere EXPLAIN this to new joiners. Although many years into this project, I haven’t really seen even the first steps towards such a thing. The PieFed instance selector came the closest to it and even sparked in me a hope that it would meet that need, but progress on that seems to have been abandoned and suggestions for PieFed to improve it have gone ignored for something like a year or so now. I doubt it will ever be carried forward, in that venue.
Agreed about the swimming pool illustration regarding onboarding, except it’s far worse than that even: we here all learned GENTLY as the waters slowly rise about us, so we each picked up a few new concepts as the years trickled (or sped?) past us. New joiners are being asked to suddenly learn all of it at once, and even worse than that besides, to do so prior to making an account. One example: if you visit Lemmy.ml without an account you will see a Local listing of posts, which I believe is the software default for all newly created instances. Potential new joiners are not shown what is possible from observing that instance, unless they poke around sufficiently enough to notice the All button and see federated content as well. Another example is that I know of no possible way to view an instance’s set of rules from within Voyager. That entire sidebar might as well not exist for people using Voyager, which unfortunately also seems the most likely scenario for a new joiner coming here from Reddit?
I don’t like questionaires, but something along the lines of the PieFed instance picker where the information is all laid out, filtering is possible based on it, and sentences explain the various choices possible would be a great way forward, if someone were willing to take up that project.
So, I looked at the post without being logged in and I see your point. It seems I have blocked a fair share of contentious people. FiniteBanjo appears to be the only one that hasn’t warranted a block. My mistake for not checking an unfiltered version of the post. Appreciate the correction :)
That sounds like a pretty cool feature. I don’t link I’ve ever seen it implemented in the threadiverse though.
Yeah, we’re definitely on the slower road :/
Do you have a source? Not trying to disagree, genuinely curious to look at the data. Activity Data puts Lemmy.world users originating/creating less than a 1/3 of total activity. So, it’d be interesting if everyone goes to lemmy.world communities. I know Mia’s Community Growth Posts often have Lemmy.world communities with the most new subscribers, but I don’t know if they have the most “active” communities by total number (posts, comments, visiting users).
Yeah, better/any on-boarding is really needed.
I would actually go the other way and say things have calmed way down compared to like a year ago. I really thought the threadiverse was going to split during the false evidence against the anarchists and .world admin calls to de-federate. It seems, to me, that everyone has taken a step back and mostly just stays out of each other’s way now, which isn’t getting along, but doesn’t appear to be actively antagonistic.
I think, even if it did split, it wouldn’t be a unified split. All the “non-aligned” instances (not neo-liberal, not ml, not anarchist) is like 50% of the threadiverse and they would still see everything. So, I expect the “non-aligned” instances would increase in size and the “aligned” instances would decrease in size. Which is kind of what the data shows (all three “aligned” groups show decreases (anarchists the least) and “non-aligned” increasing on average).
Yeah, unfortunately not enough developers/admin/mods/supporters to go around at this point. I already have a number of my own projects that don’t have enough time devoted to them, but I’m open to working on some on-boarding features/pitches with you, if you’re interested.
I agree about Voyager’s inability to see the instance sidebar/set-of-rules. I made a post about it. We’ll see what happens.
Blaze had calculated that at some point. It was quite awhile ago so that could have changed radically since then but… based on all of my personal experience things seem to mostly be moving in the opposite direction. e.g. as mander.xyz and slrpnk.net are both down (hopefully just temporarily), and smaller communities struggling mightily hence people remain in the biggest ones.
One example is [email protected] retaining 5.77K MAUs compared to its offshoot [email protected] with just 0.08K MAUs. And I mentioned others like [email protected] previously. You likely see this happening all across the entire Threadiverse. We cannot support much niche content so it generalizes instead. The trends towards centralization are not being counter-balanced as much as previously by trends away from that.
It does seem believable to me though, that separately from all MAUs, the number of existing communities that people post into are concentrated on LW. Again, there was a huge shift to try to spread them around, but that was before the Flotilla began threatening to split the Threadiverse in two in consolidation with anarchist.nexus, and I for one tend not to post into communities located on dbzero anymore (I am not like morally opposed to such, but I just don’t try to prioritize it as I once used to).
That is probably due to your having blocked a lot of it? But if you narrowly mean between AN & DB0 vs. LW then yeah to that much. Although I recall reading in the DB0 meta community that the call to defederate from LW was postponed: (1) for something like half to one year, for preemptively defederating then - i.e. this calming down period was intentional yet a vote as to whether to continue was still on the schedule even in the heat of it all, and also (2) separately from that, virtually a guarantee to happen if any single member of the Flotilla ever gets defederated from, I think this one not merely by LW but by any instance whatsoever, anywhere. That is no mere threat about some future vote that may or may not happen - that is outright policy, a settled matter, iirc.
Again, not that any of this stuff is easy to keep up with, even by us here, to say nothing of newcomers.
That assumption might not be true. If the Flotilla defederates not merely from LW but from any instance that remains federated with it, then the schism would be wide indeed. But we’d have to read more the Flotilla policy to see (again) their stated aims. I forget the likelihood of this being true, but it’s definitely nonzero and more than just a vague conspiracy theory - whether it actually happens or not, people were most definitely clamoring for exactly that to occur, and it was not a fringe opinion iirc. Then again, after the cooling period, things probably will look different, so most likely the most extremist opinions will be drowned out by those wanting the greater convenience of remaining connected.
I will now go read your post:-).
If there are multiple “active” communities of the same type on different instances, I tend to block .ml, .world, and .social communities (with the goal of helping de-centralization). So, I don’t have a good understanding of what an un-curated experience is like.
I think a more equitable comparison would be with [email protected], that has “2K Monthly Users”.
In the short term, I don’t see this as particularly problematic, as long as the communities are dispersed across instances (helps congregate activity / seem more active).
I take the opposite view of that event. I see the flotilla as protecting against an authoritarian action by the .world admins, in the same vein/idea as “Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.”. I have no faith the .world admins would have stopped at anarchist.nexus or would in the future.
Definitely possible. In a slightly related tangent, it looks like Piefed copied Pylova’s user block lists, but implemented them in an incompatible way. Also, possibly breaking instance conversion from Piefed to Pylova. Ugh…
My recollection is that defederation would only happen to instances that de-federated from a member of the flotilla (like .world). De-federating from anyone that federates with .world would be massive self sabotage (in my view). Hopefully, that’s not what happens.
Oh yes, the largest communities here are toxic shitholes. Politics, Memes, News, Comics, all are high contentious battlegrounds. Tbf the same is true and in fact far worse on Reddit, or was before the most heavy extremists were banned and now they are here instead of there anymore.
And if a new joiner came here and did not block as you did, they would have an extremely skewed perspective of this place. Numerically speaking though, it is your (and Blaze, and my) perspective that is different from the normal. Exception: PieFed.social bans all 3 of the tankie triad right away for new accounts, so that does significantly reduce that issue.
The history of TenForward was that the user Stamets had some drama with the [email protected] mods and went off and started his own community, along with NegativeNull, ThePicardManeuver, and then Ummthatguy joined later, and then Stamets left and went off to make his own second Risa, [email protected]. Anyway, if you look at the mod teams of the two TenForward communities that I mentioned, you will see that they are identical. So those two I would say are the most apt comparison - one is on Lemmy and the other on PieFed, but all other factors are the same.
Except one: TenForward on LW was the original community, and the PieFed one came along later, without much promotion from pretty much anyone that I’ve seen. There definitely is a strong effect whereby since the OG one is still present, and extremely highly active (one of the largest communities across the entire Threadiverse), that people stick with the OG one and have no need for the other. Especially when PieFed.World barely exists itself - see e.g. the paltry showing at https://piefed.world/topics, despite the multi-comnunity topic feed areas being one of the most popular features of the PieFed software platform.
There once was excitement that PieFed was going to overtake Lemmy. Now, even with v1.0 having been delayed for 18 months as you said, the excitement about PieFed is shrinking or already over. This here that exists now is pretty much what the Threadiverse will be for the next decade, as we continue to lose more people than we gain over time, and the software tools go into maintenance mode with a declining audience for their features offered.
Agreed - this is what must be, the only issue is that new joiners need to adjust to it, like communities don’t exist for specific games so much as just a gigantic “games” community, and at best perhaps an exceedingly generalized genre (but not finer-grained subgenres).
I was not trying to pass a moral judgement there, just stating it as almost a foregone conclusion that the Threadiverse is going to split. And then I added those details about who is going to cause it and why they said that they would. Also, the end result will be even fewer visitors to the Threadiverse, as even the upcoming tension that it might happen may already be affecting people’s recommendations as to what instances to join (regardless of whether or not it should happen or not, which I suppose mainly turns on whether the evidence was faked or not, which I admittedly haven’t bothered to examine as I see that point as irrelevant to the endpoint). Once again that increases the “complexity” required to be able to navigate this place.
Here we are free. This is no walled garden, or rather it is many gardens, or I prefer the analogy instead of free trader and pirate ships. The downside is that you leave behind “civilization” when you come here - there are no kings, not exactly, but there are fiefdoms, and you either need to learn how to self-host your own boat (which in today’s modern climate is hellish due to all the LLM scrapers ignoring all rules and traditions alike, presumably even targeting single-user instances), or learn how to navigate all of this complexity. i.e. there are responsibilities that come with this freedom.
None of which Reddit / X / Threads / Insta / Tiktok demands of them. So (most of them) will simply remain there.
User blocklists: I saw that they were added!:-) But not that they were incompatible:-(. Of all the petulance… :-|
Related to your personal blocking (me too ofc, as with most Lemmings): you tend to miss out on such gems as https://lemmy.ml/post/55085010/28894101 (link is to a comment but the entire post is illustrative as well), and also this post https://lemmy.ml/post/54724340?sort=Top - make sure to sort comments by Hot or Top and see especially (but not exclusively) the top one. Calls for literal murder tend to turn mainstream normies away. We are an extremist / tankie bar here, whether some of us block it out or not, numerically such posts remain and new joiners are extremely likely to stumble upon them. Especially if they pick Lemmy.ml as the flagship instance, which shows Local rather than All posts to a guest viewing without an account.
Every single person that I have mentioned the Lemmy platform to has outright chided me for telling them about it. We block, but new joiners don’t know how yet, and to them, the above pair of posts mostly exemplifies what this place is. An extremist place, highly opinionated, and not terribly welcoming to mainstream folk, who tend to be centrist, religious, and non-technical, unlike the prevailing trends here.
My block list is probably doing me many favors in regard to those.
Yeah, I think getting more instances to institute an initial user-level instance block for the “triad” instances (like .zip) may be the best return on effort, at this point.
I recalled the Star Trek communities splintered, but didn’t remember the specifics.
I think we might have been discussing different points. It seems, to me, you may have been talking about Lemmy vs. Piefed and I was talking about Plurality/Flag-ship instances vs not.
Yeah, not many people holding Piefed’s ‘water’ at this point.
I don’t know that we will still be like this in a decade, I still consider the Threadiverse to be at a ‘Beta’ version level (maybe ‘Alpha’). As bad as it may look at times, we aren’t losing users faster than we are gaining them, actually +3.8% compared to a year ago).
I like that you brought the games community up, it seems like that is the only area right now big enough to host a variety of more niche active communities (ex. tabletop, patient gamers). So, might be the closest to breaking out into more singular communities (ex. [email protected], but possibly GTA6 will be the first majorly active one, assuming it’s not already and I’ve blocked it).
I’m going to still disagree that, if it were to happen, it would not be the flotilla causing it. In my view, the entity causing the response is the responsible party (like if Russia invaded a Baltic country and NATO declared war on Russia, Russia would have caused the war, not NATO).
Possible I haven’t seen those discussions due to my blocks.
I like your analogy. Never heard of the “free trader and pirate ships” version (flotilla == pirate ships, I’d guess).
Well said.
Yep… :(
Yeah, my thoughts exactly. Plus breaking the Piefed -> Pylova conversion, seems to me Rimu is trying to wall his garden.
I was expecting much worse, based on what you were saying. I see where you’re coming from, but I don’t think posting or writing about a guillotine is that radical. I think most people don’t think the law works and isn’t likely to justice for the leaders/rich/whatever that are abusing/imprisoning/torturing/murdering/genociding people in broad daylight. So, not surprising to me they would call back to one of the well known times that those types of people got “justice”.
Another way you may want to consider is, what’s the difference between beating someone to death, starving them to death, poisoning to death (via tainted drinking water), withholding lifesaving medicine (ex. cancer treatment), or working someone to death. They all lead to death, usually just on different timelines and with different levels of direct interaction.
If a CEO jacks up the price of life saving medicine 1000% and now 10,000 people can no longer afford it and they die, did that CEO kill them? Some may say no, others may say yes. If the answer was yes, then if some random rich person is killing thousands a day/month/year/whatever, and the law will likely never touch them, what should someone do? If the only answer people give them is vote every other year, and hope that something that has never happened in their live happens, I don’t think many tempers will be quenched and people will search for and call for other solutions.
As in they checked it out and ran away screaming?
“religious” is an unexpected inclusion. I almost never run into anyone religious IRL or online. “centrist” is also a curious point, who’s “centrist” (American, European, Canadian, South Pacific, other; they are all different)? I think your environment may be affecting your viewpoint here.
Edit: New community you might want to check out: [email protected]